You Won’t Forget Me by Mazey Eddings: My Honest Book Review
*Disclosure: This post may include affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
⭐ Quick Verdict
⭐ My Rating: 4 ★
💭 Quick Take: An emotionally intense sapphic friends-to-lovers romance that trades light rock star chaos for something far more vulnerable, painful, and ultimately rewarding.
👉 Read If You Love:
- Friends-to-lovers angst
- Queer awakening stories
- Rock star romance with emotional depth
- Slow burn tension
- Musical lyrics woven throughout the story
- Romance novels that tackle toxic internet culture head-on
🚫 Skip if:
- Online trolling and social media pile-ons make you uncomfortable
- You’re looking for a lighter or more comedic rock star romance
- You want high steam over emotional tension
Book Details
Release Date: June 2026
Genre: Queer Romance, Sapphic Romance, Contemporary Romance
Tropes: Friends to Lovers, Rock Star Romance, Forced Proximity, Queer Awakening, Fake Dating
Steam Level: Medium
Part of a Series: Standalone
What This Book Is About
Cubby is part of a rising band navigating fame, public scrutiny, and the constant pressure to maintain an image that keeps everyone happy – from fans to record executives. But behind the scenes, her life feels increasingly messy thanks to a toxic ex, relentless online commentary, and the emotional exhaustion that comes with trying to survive in the spotlight.
Then there’s Darcy, the friend who has always been there in the background. As the tension between them slowly shifts into something deeper, Cubby is forced to confront not only her feelings but also questions about identity, self-worth, and what it actually means to be seen for who you are.
What unfolds is a deeply emotional friends-to-lovers romance layered with queer awakening, fake dating complications, mental health struggles, and the brutal realities of internet culture.
My Review of You Won’t Forget Me
Mazey Eddings has truly become a force in queer romance, and she absolutely nailed it again with You Won’t Forget Me. She mentioned in her acknowledgements that this was a difficult book to write, and honestly, you can feel that emotional weight on every page.
I actually went into this expecting something lighter – a fun sapphic rock star romance with humor, steam, and band shenanigans. But what Mazey delivers is far more emotionally layered. This is a romance built in the middle of public scrutiny, toxic relationship dynamics, internet cruelty, and the exhausting pressure of celebrity culture.
And honestly? The way she portrays gaslighting and toxic online behavior was almost too effective at times. There were moments where I felt genuinely uncomfortable reading what Cubby was being subjected to – not because it was poorly done, but because it felt painfully realistic. Watching her get manipulated by her ex, criticized online, and pressured by people around her “for the good of the band” was heartbreaking in a way that hit harder than I expected.
The friends-to-lovers romance itself unfolds beautifully. The emotional tension between Cubby and Darcy builds slowly, and Mazey gives their connection space to feel authentic rather than rushed. There’s a tenderness to their relationship that balances some of the heavier themes, and when they finally get their happily ever after, it genuinely feels earned.
I also really loved how thoughtfully the queer awakening storyline was handled. It never felt performative or overly dramatized. Instead, it felt messy, emotional, confusing, and deeply human in a way that made Cubby’s journey resonate even more.
While not a huge part of the story, I have to mention the songwriting. Mazey is genuinely talented at writing lyrics, which made the musical elements when there feel like an added bonus to this storyline.
This book also weaves in themes of depression, parental support and judgment, fake dating complications, and the emotional cost of fame without losing sight of the romance at the center. Plus, longtime readers will appreciate seeing Tilly and Oliver again since Cubby is Oliver’s twin sister.
This made my list of most anticipated queer romances of 2026, and somehow it still exceeded expectations.
What I Loved
- A queer awakening storyline that felt authentic
- Friends-to-lovers tension that slowly builds in a believable way
- The emotional vulnerability between Cubby and Darcy
- Mazey’s lyric writing genuinely impressed me
- Honest portrayal of toxic internet culture and celebrity scrutiny
- Strong mental health representation woven naturally into the story
- Nod to dentistry and oral surgery since Mazey is a dentist 😊
- Cameos from Tilly and Oliver from Tilly in Technicolor
Things to Know Before You Read
- Heavy themes surrounding online harassment and public shaming
- Gaslighting and emotional manipulation from a toxic ex
- Depression representation
- Fake dating setup that becomes emotionally painful for the heroine
- Includes both supportive and judgmental parental dynamics
- Slower emotional build rather than a highly plot-driven romance
- Medium steam with two open-door scenes
- Standalone romance
Final Thoughts
You Won’t Forget Me ended up being far more emotionally intense than I expected, but also far more rewarding. This isn’t a fluffy rock star romance built around celebrity fantasy. It’s a deeply vulnerable story about identity, friendship, public perception, and finding someone who truly sees you underneath all the noise.
If you love emotionally layered friends-to-lovers romances with queer awakening themes, complicated emotional dynamics, and heroines who have to fight hard for their happiness, this one is absolutely worth picking up.
And after this? I’ll continue reading whatever Mazey Eddings writes next.
I received an advance reader copy. All opinions are my own.
More Books by Mazey:
📚 Want more romance recs like this?
Get my weekly list of the best new romance books (plus the ones actually worth your time).
