Pen Pal Afterlife by J.T. Geissinger: My Honest Book Review
*Disclosure: This post may include affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
โญ Quick Verdict
โญ My Rating: 3 โ
๐ญ Quick Take: A unique sequel that fans of Pen Pal will enjoy but definitely takes a turn into the unusual.
๐ Read If You Love:
- Sequels about your favorite couples
- Interesting commentary on reincarnation and the afterlife
๐ซ Skip if:
- You were hoping for more steaminess between this couple and a typical happily ever after
Book Details
Release Date: November 2026
Genre: Paranormal Romance
Tropes: Ghosts
Steam Level: Low to Moderate
My Review of Pen Pal Afterlife
I have to give it to J.T.; she can craft some unique stories! I was gobsmacked after reading Pen Pal, which I think is one of her masterpieces. It is such a unique and steamy love story in one where I was completely captivated by Aiden and Kayla. To have her return to this amazing couple with this sequel was so exciting. And while I enjoyed this book and found it to be equally as unique, Iโm not sure it will appeal to all readers.
For one, most of this story focuses on their โlimboโ and trying to figure out where they are, what is now happening to their safe haven, and what they have to do to prevent separating from each other. I personally liked all the commentary J.T. sprinkles throughout about reincarnation, creating your own reality, multiverses and the like. But overall, the story is definitely dark and maybe a bit confusing in parts which for me overshadowed the soulmate level of love that I fell for between Aiden and Kayla when reading Pen Pal. Yes, we get a few steamy scenes where this love is expressed, but this is definitely a different type of romance.
I for one, will read whatever J.T. writes, but this one lacked the twists I was expecting and was overall darker with a storyline that wasnโt always easy to follow or maybe itโs just one I wasnโt anticipating. If you read Pen Pal and loved it, I think this is definitely a sequel to read, but I donโt think it would land the same way if read as a standalone.
As a side note โ the Pen Pal original cover was FIRE, so I expected this cover to blow me away, but it is actually quite lackluster.
I received an advance reader copy. All opinions are my own.
If You Liked This, Read Next
๐ Want more romance recs like this?
Get my free Ultimate Romance Trope Starter Guide with my handpicked recommendations for the romance tropes readers love most. You’ll also receive my weekly newsletter featuring new releases, mini reviews, and trusted romance book recommendations.


